
As the topic of the European Union (EU) joining the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) has been in a stand-off for almost ten years, we asked Prof. Thierry Rambaud, Professor of Public law at the Paris-Cité University and a Lawyer at the Paris bar, to shed some light on the obstacles posed by this prospect, which remains unfulfilled since it was provided for in the Treaty of Lisbon (2009). According to him, the arguments invoked by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), in its negative opinion of 2014, remain valid, and should not be forgotten. Moreover, the European Union already takes the issue of the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms very seriously.
Q1. The EU’s accession to the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) was already on the list of objectives of the Treaty of Lisbon fifteen years ago. Could you tell us why it was deemed necessary back then to include this element, and whether you think that this step would still make sense today?
You are right to point out that the European Union’s accession to the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) is provided for in the Treaty of Lisbon (TEU) in which Article 6 paragraph 2 stipulates: “2. The Union shall accede to the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Such accession shall not affect the Union’s competences as defined in the Treaties.” The use of the present indicative tense seems to impose an obligation on the Member States and institutions of the European Union to conclude this accession process. However, in the Opinion 2/13 that was delivered, which is quite rare in practice and proof of the importance of the subject, in its plenary on the 18th of December 2014, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), on the basis of Article 213 paragraph 11 of the TFEU, ruled that the draft accession agreement that had been drawn up did not comply with European Union law. I would like to remind you that the 28 Member States of the European Union did support this draft agreement. The Court invoked arguments relating both to the institutional structure of the European Union and the deep-seated characteristics of European Union law. It is true that the accession process is just subjecting the actions of the European institutions to the control of an external judicial body: the European Court of Human Rights. Beyond the technical reasons, it is clear to everyone that this process has a highly sensitive political dimension that is likely to ruffle certain feathers. The negative opinion of 2014 followed a first negative opinion issued on the 28th of March 1996.
The vast majority of the legal and political literature was enthusiastic about this accession process. On our side, we were more reserved due to the adage: “perfect is the enemy of good”. We also believe that fundamental rights are already well protected in the European Union. In addition to the important case law of the CJEU on the protection of fundamental rights, the Union also adopted in December 2000 a European Charter of Fundamental Rights to which the Treaty of Lisbon gave legal standing. Furthermore, the institutions and courts of the Member States are primarily responsible for protecting fundamental rights. Council Regulation 168/2007/EC dated the 15th of February 2007 establishes a European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights to strengthen the expertise and the competence of the European institutions and Member States in the sphere of fundamental rights. This means that the European Union, before even launching the accession process to the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR), was already taking the issue of human rights and fundamental freedoms very seriously.
Q2. And yet, in 2023, the EU still is not a member of the ECHR. What are the main obstacles? Could you explain to us what has not worked up until this point?
The debate regularly comes to the fore in Europe, without the basic facts of the issue having really changed. However, it would be an important step which, for many legal experts, would harmonise the European system for the protection of rights and freedoms in Europe. The structural obstacles are listed in the CJEU’s opinion of 2014. They relate, as was mentioned before, to the deep-seated characteristics of European Union law. Let us take the example of the second incompatibility relating to the “principle of mutual trust between the Member States”. We know that the European Convention of Human Rights requires Member States to verify the respect of fundamental rights by another Member State. Such verification would be incompatible with the principle of mutual trust between States. The Court mentioned many other arguments relating to the co-respondent mechanism or the CFSP (Common Foreign and Security Policy), the latter undoubtedly being the most sensitive issue.
Let us quickly remind ourselves what the co-respondent principle is, which was perfectly summarised by Professor Jacqué, eminent professor at the University of Strasbourg and at the College of Europe in Bruges and Honorary Director General at the Council of the European Union: “The protection of the distribution of competences between the Member States and the EU is ensured by the co-respondent system, which allows a State or the EU, as the case may be, to stand alongside the initial respondent and to form a single party with them. In this way, the European Court of Human Rights need not ask itself at the admissibility stage whether the contested measure falls within the competences of the EU or of the Member State in question”. (J-P. Jacqué, « L’avis 2/13 CJUE. Non à l’adhésion à la Convention européenne des droits de l’Homme ? » [“CJEU Opinion 2/13. No to accession to the European Convention of Human Rights?”], https://free-group.eu/2014/12/26/, accessed on 20 January 2023) The difficulty is that it is up to the European Court of Human Rights to assess whether the conditions are fulfilled so that the status of co-respondent can be accepted.
These difficulties should not overshadow all the other progress that this accession project has yielded (appointment of judges, etc.). However, as Professor Jean-Paul Jacqué said so well in the study I previously quoted: “The challenge presented by accession is difficult to overcome. The European Convention of Human Rights is originally an inter-state treaty to which it is proposed that an entity of a federal nature, which is most certainly not a State, accede”.
Q3. There are many instances of cross-referencing between the Court of Justice of the EU and the European Court of Human Rights, with one referencing the case law of the other. Is there a chance that this will lead to a renewed momentum on the issue of rapprochement between the EU and the ECHR?
To be sure, the Courts of Luxembourg and Strasbourg closely examine each other’s rulings. This is the “dialogue of judges”, a favourite expression of French Councillor of State, Bruno Genevois. But I must admit that I believe that the subject has become a recurring issue that constantly rears its head on the front pages of European news, but I must ask one question: have the structural obstacles underscored in the Court’s opinion disappeared? I think that the answer is no. Already, in October 2019, the European Commission transmitted to the Secretary General of the Council of Europe the Commission’s wish to resume the accession process. The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe adopted a mandate for negotiations in 2020. However, I am not very optimistic. I share Professor Jacqué’s analysis in the aforementioned text: the opinion basically raises the crucial issue (of compatibility, EDITOR’S NOTE) of the relationship between the interstate system embodied by the Council of Europe and the integration model represented by the European Union.
But let us not think that non-accession would open up the doors to a “legal vacuum”. The European Court of Human Rights already exercises control over European Union acts, under certain conditions, of course. The case law Bosphorus Airways v. Ireland of 30 June 2005 continues to apply in this case. It is also important to remember that the European Charter of Fundamental Rights has full legal force and is now binding, not only for EU institutions, bodies and agencies, but also for Member States. The reservations that the British had are no longer relevant because of Brexit.
Q4. One of the issues regularly raised by Eurosceptic movements is the supposed lack of legal accountability of the European institutions relating to fundamental rights. What do you make of these criticisms, and to what extent would EU accession to the ECHR address this?
No, I think that the answer lies elsewhere. The Court of Justice of the EU already ensures that fundamental rights are respected, as well as national constitutional case law, such as that of the German Constitutional Court that has adopted quite a remarkable case law in the matter. We must not expect any miracles resulting from this hypothetical accession, but we must work tirelessly to strengthen democratic and citizen control over the functioning of the European institutions. This is one of my recurring themes: bringing the European institutions closer to its citizens. The latter are generally unaware of how they are organised and how they work. A good political system, (which the EU has), is based, above all, on the relationship of trust between the governors and the governed. However, despite the democratic progress made since the Treaty of Maastricht in 1992, it is clear that the divide continues to increase between institutions and citizens. However, constant efforts are being made to reduce this gap (see the excellent initiatives of EDUC-EU in this regard).
Interview conducted on 20 January 2023






